Framework and Library Evaluation Policy and Process

Framework and Library Evaluation Policy and Process

Objective: The purpose of this policy is to establish a structured and collaborative approach for evaluating new frameworks and libraries to be integrated into our software product. The goal is to ensure that the selected technologies align with our project requirements, maintainability, scalability, and long-term goals.

1. Framework/Library Proposal:

  • Any team member can propose the adoption of a new framework or library by submitting a proposal to the team lead.
  • The proposal should include a clear explanation of the need, potential benefits, and how it aligns with the project's objectives.

2. Initial Assessment:

  • The team lead, in collaboration with relevant stakeholders, will conduct an initial assessment of the proposed framework/library.
  • Considerations include compatibility with existing technologies, licensing, community support, and alignment with the project's technical stack.

3. Technical Evaluation Team:

  • Form a technical evaluation team comprising a cross-functional group of team members with relevant expertise.
  • Include individuals who will be directly impacted by the adoption of the new technology.
  • Front end technology will be evaluated by the front end team, with input from team leads.
  • Back end technology will be evaluated by the back end team, with input from team leads.

4. Evaluation Criteria:

  • Define a set of criteria for evaluating frameworks/libraries, including but not limited to:
    • Performance
    • Scalability
    • Learning curve
    • Community support
    • Documentation
    • Compatibility with existing tools and systems
    • Security considerations
    • Licensing

5. Research and Analysis:

  • The evaluation team will conduct thorough research on the proposed framework/library.
  • Perform practical tests, create prototypes, and analyze the results against the predefined criteria.

6. Documentation:

  • Create a write-up documenting the findings of the evaluation. This does not need to be long but should contain relevant points.
  • Include technical analysis, pros and cons, and recommendations.

7. Presentation and Discussion:

  • The evaluation team will present their findings to the development.
  • Encourage open discussions and address any concerns or questions raised.

8. Trial Integration:

  • If feasible, conduct a trial integration of the selected framework/library into a non-production environment.
  • Evaluate its performance and impact on the existing codebase.

9. Feedback and Iteration:

  • Gather feedback from team members during the trial integration phase.
  • Iterate on the evaluation process based on the feedback received.

10. Decision Making:

  • The team lead will make the final decision on whether to adopt the new framework/library.

11. Documentation and Training:

  • If the decision is to adopt the new technology, create documentation for onboarding and training team members.
  • Conduct training sessions to ensure a smooth transition.

12. Monitoring and Review:

  • Regularly monitor the performance and impact of the adopted framework/library.
  • Conduct periodic reviews to assess its continued relevance and effectiveness.

Note: This policy is designed to be flexible and can be adapted based on the specific needs and processes of the development team. Regularly review and update the policy as the team evolves and new technologies emerge. Input from all team members is crucial in maintaining a dynamic and effective evaluation process.

 


    • Related Articles

    • Code Review Policy

      Code Review Policy Objective: The primary goal of our code review process is to ensure high-quality, maintainable, and efficient code that aligns with the team's standards and best practices. Code reviews serve as a collaborative effort to enhance ...

    • Andorid Tablet Evaluation Process

      Current Android Offerings: https://kb.fullcount.net/documentation/fullcount-hardware-links Check to see if any of our current offerings have been end-of-lifed using https://endoflife.date/samsung-mobile. 1. Go through our list of approved android ...

    • Developer Guide

      Installations An installation guide can be found in the Setup a New Developer Machine guide. Version Control Guide We use both Subversion and Git for version control. A crashcourse of our Subversion versioning processes can be found in the Subversion ...

    • Process Mode

      Process Mode Process mode allows communities to set up a processing order to take multiple orders at one time in sequence. Then each group of orders can be processed at once by being sent to the kitchen and closed. This is typically used in a ...

    • Remote Deployment Process - Java

      Deployment Process Determine if a valid argument has been passed in Only continue if downloadOnly, postDownload, fullDeployment, handleSuccess, checkHash, verifyApplications passed through. Lock file to stop deployment from running more than once ...